Why I regret buying an LED TV

This is the story of an idiot who bought a top of the range LED TV three years ago and has regretted it ever since.

My previous TV was a much loved Panasonic Plasma but after several years of enjoying its fantastic picture, it was time to upgrade to something bigger with HD, streaming capability and kick ass 3D. Yes, I admit it, I like 3D.

I was all set to buy another Panasonic but didn’t want the active 3D system or the energy hungry, radiator heat of a plasma TV that tended to buzz after a while. And neither did I want something so heavy that it required an elephant to carry it home and a complex series of pulleys to hoist it into position, complete with a voucher for a free hernia operation.

The answer then was LED. Now, all LED TV’s are actually LCD TV’s that use a backlight for the image, the difference being that with LED, the light is provided via LED lights and not conventional lamps. The TV we decided on was an LG that was smart-enabled with passive 3D and the full suite of streaming options such as BBC iPlayer and DLNA.

The image on the Panasonic was always a bit dim and dull so the brighter LG was much more impressive. I spent some time setting it up but the big problem was and always has been and still is to this very day with all LED TV’s, the complete lack of any deep inky blacks. You can forget all the other specifications and scams like 4K, when it comes to judging image quality, one of the main criteria, if not THE main criteria, is how a TV can handle black colours.

With a plasma set, it’s perfectly black since the areas with black are actually switched off. With a shitty LED though, the light is always shining from behind the picture and the options available are limited to either dim the LED light locally or fiddle with the settings for dynamic contrast, black levels, brightness, backlight and all other manner of crap that interferes with the actual image. Regardless, the result is a washed out dark grey rather than jet black and terrible light bleed that once you notice, you can never not notice again. Films in particular are much less watchable because of the borders at the top and bottom which are school uniform grey and hugely distracting.

Tweaking the settings does help but the compromise is severe; enable the LED local dimming or reducing the backlight means that you get darker blacks at the expense of a dimmer image. Bump up the contrast or brightness to counter this and the picture starts to lose detail and focus. In short, there is no suitable compromise with an LED TV, even if it is fully backlit rather than the cheaper edge-lit. Buy one and you can look forward to years of watching TV’s with unconvincing black levels.

The light bleed in particular has gotten worse and will only deteriorate further. And then there’s the viewing angle. Unless you’re sat slap bang in front of an LED at the right height, the picture contrast suffers and you get a very uneven image with areas of light and dark. Stand up or sit down from you plum viewing spot and even then, the picture will change. As for the poor sods sitting at the side and having to view from a 60 degree angle, you might as well just tell them to leave the room. A plasma set has none of these issues and you could be standing at a 20 degree angle from the set and still enjoy the show.

If I could go back three years and choose again, I’d definitely say fuck LED, I’m sticking with plasma. However, given that plasma has now stopped being made, the only hope is OLED which, like plasma, manages deep velvety blacks and suffers no viewing angle limitations. In fact, OLED is even better than plasma as it’s thinner, brighter, lighter and even requires even less power than an LED TV. In short, OLED offers all of the advantages of both plasma and LED with none of the drawbacks.

Except one; cost. OLED is still too expensive to make so expect to pay a premium for one, especially since none of the other manufacturers apart from LG seem bothered to go down the OLED route and instead, are intent on pushing those stupid fuckin’ 4K TV’s that nobody wants.

I reckon it’s a premium worth paying though so my LG LED is up for sale and quite frankly, I can’t get shot of it quick enough to replace it with an OLED model.

2 Responses to Why I regret buying an LED TV

  1. j7n says:

    The “LED” designation seems to have been created to mislead buyers into thinking it’s a new type of monitor without the well known low contrast and angle of LCD flat screens. I dislike the grey blacks as well. I can see them on computer monitor when playing games, but I never went through the shock of suddenly seeing them, because prior to having a flat screen, I had a Sony Trinitron which had deteriorated so that brightness could no longer be brought down to zero with the controls. In fact the replacement LCD happened to be an improvement.

    The 4K resolution is a gimick intended to sell new products. There won’t be enough bandwidth allocated to any TV channel to fill such a screen with meaningful detail on every pixel, nor will there be discs large enough for that. 4K pixels with plastic shapes oversharpened at the edges, no thank you. It’s too bad they haven’t figured out how to market an increase in bitrate or removal of chroma subsampling.

    • Grumpy Bear says:

      Indeed. Walk into any store of John Lewis or Currys here in the UK and nearly all the TV’s are 4K models. Apparently, they are selling well, far better than 3D ever did but that doesn’t make them any more necessary or relevant. I reckon it’s just a a question of cost, a 4K TV can be had for about a grand whereas an OLED TV at the same size cost more than double.

      LG has just announced a major ramp up of OLED panels in preference to LCD so hopefully this will lead to more competitive prices. Plasma was the same when it first launched, it took about 5 years for it to reach a price point that made it a viable alternative. The difference though is that there was more than one company interested in selling plasma displays. With OLED, the problem is that it’s still expensive to manufacture so nobody else seems interested. Samsung only wants to flog 4K TV’s, Sony has said they have no interest in OLED and is pushing Triluminos and Panasonic is still trying to make money from selling any kind of TV after years of loss making, but fabulous, plasma panels.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: